In early 2025, U.S. Representative Buddy Carter (R-Ga.) officially nominated former President Donald Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize, citing his role in brokering a ceasefire during the recent escalation between Israel and Iran. The nomination drew widespread media attention due to the timing of ongoing hostilities and raised questions about the criteria and process for awarding the Nobel Peace Prize.
Background on the Israel-Iran Conflict
In mid-June 2025, tensions between Israel and Iran sharply escalated following Israeli strikes on targets linked to Iran’s nuclear program. Israel described these actions as necessary to prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons capabilities, an accusation Iran has consistently denied.
International monitoring agencies, including the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), have long expressed concerns about Iran’s nuclear enrichment activities. According to the IAEA’s 2024 reports, Iran has been enriching uranium to levels just below weapons-grade thresholds, heightening global tensions and fears of proliferation. [Sources: IAEA Safeguards Reports, United Nations Security Council Resolutions on Iran]
During the conflict, both sides engaged in a series of retaliatory attacks. Israel used precision air strikes, while Iran reportedly launched ballistic missiles toward Israeli territory. This exchange threatened broader regional stability and raised alarms among neighboring states and international observers, including the United Nations. [Source: BBC News, Reuters]
U.S. Diplomatic Efforts to Broker a Ceasefire
Amid the escalation, the United States sought to reduce hostilities. Former President Donald Trump, though no longer in office, was credited by some political allies with playing an advisory or informal diplomatic role. According to public statements by Rep. Buddy Carter, Trump used his relationships with Middle Eastern leaders to help secure a ceasefire agreement aimed at ending the 12-day conflict.
The agreement’s terms, as reported in U.S. and Israeli media, included:
-
A halt to Israeli air strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities.
-
A cessation of Iranian ballistic missile attacks on Israeli cities.
-
A mutual commitment to de-escalation monitored indirectly via diplomatic channels.
Israeli officials, including government spokespersons, publicly thanked the United States for its role in facilitating dialogue. However, there was no formal treaty or multilateral monitoring mission deployed to enforce the agreement. [Sources: The Times of Israel, CNN]
The Nobel Peace Prize Nomination by Rep. Buddy Carter
On June 25, 2025, Rep. Buddy Carter confirmed he had submitted a formal nomination to the Norwegian Nobel Committee. In his letter, Carter cited Trump’s “extraordinary and historic role” in helping end active hostilities. Carter argued that Trump’s influence was “instrumental” in reaching a ceasefire that might otherwise have proven elusive. [Source: Rep. Buddy Carter’s official website, U.S. Congressional Records]
The Nobel Peace Prize nomination process allows any national legislator, university professor in certain fields, former laureate, or senior government official to make nominations. Such nominations do not guarantee selection or even shortlisting, and the Committee does not comment on specific nominees until 50 years later, per its rules. [Source: The Nobel Foundation]
Challenges and Questions Around the Ceasefire’s Durability
The ceasefire was announced late on June 24, 2025, with implementation scheduled for the following day. Israeli officials described the deal as a success in achieving their primary goal of weakening Iran’s nuclear program infrastructure.
However, within 24 hours, news agencies reported renewed hostilities. According to the Associated Press and Reuters, Israeli defense officials claimed Iran launched at least two ballistic missiles toward Israeli territory despite the ceasefire. In response, Israel conducted retaliatory strikes. These developments led analysts to question whether the truce had ever been truly effective. [Sources: Reuters, Associated Press]
Such breakdowns in ceasefires are not unprecedented in regional conflicts. Middle East security experts often note that initial agreements may be fragile, with violations common even in the early stages of implementation. The United Nations has repeatedly called for lasting diplomatic solutions and warned against unilateral escalations that undermine fragile truces. [Source: United Nations Security Council Briefings]
Broader Context: Trump’s Middle East Policy Legacy
Former President Trump’s foreign policy record in the Middle East remains the subject of debate. His administration facilitated normalization agreements between Israel and several Arab states, collectively known as the Abraham Accords. Signed in 2020, these agreements established diplomatic relations between Israel and the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Sudan, and Morocco. The Accords are widely regarded as a significant diplomatic achievement in Arab-Israeli relations. [Source: U.S. State Department, United Nations]
Trump has previously been nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize for his role in these agreements. Though he did not receive the award, the Nobel Committee does not limit the number of times an individual can be nominated. Supporters argue that Trump’s approach reshaped Middle East alliances in a manner that reduced some forms of hostility, while critics contend that other regional conflicts, including Israel-Palestine tensions, remained unresolved. [Sources: U.S. State Department, The Norwegian Nobel Committee]
The Nobel Peace Prize Criteria and Process
The Norwegian Nobel Committee awards the Peace Prize to the individual or organization that, in its judgment, has “done the most or the best work for fraternity between nations, for the abolition or reduction of standing armies, and for the holding and promotion of peace congresses,” in line with Alfred Nobel’s 1895 will. [Source: The Nobel Foundation]
The process is highly secretive. Nominations close in January of each year, and the winner is typically announced in October. The Committee may choose from thousands of candidates and does not disclose shortlists or deliberations. Although any eligible nominator can submit a name, only the Committee’s decision is authoritative.
Public Reaction and Political Debate
Rep. Carter’s nomination of Trump sparked mixed reactions among U.S. political figures and commentators. Supporters argued it was appropriate to recognize any contribution toward halting violence and fostering negotiations, even if partial or fragile. Critics countered that the ceasefire’s apparent collapse called into question whether the diplomatic effort was successful enough to merit such a prestigious prize.
Editorials in major newspapers underscored the complexities of awarding a peace prize in an ongoing conflict zone. They noted that ceasefires often require sustained enforcement, mutual trust-building, and verification mechanisms to endure. Without these elements, agreements may break down quickly despite initial good-faith efforts. [Sources: The Washington Post, The Guardian]
Conclusion
While former President Trump’s role in promoting an Israel-Iran ceasefire drew praise from some quarters and earned him a formal Nobel Peace Prize nomination, the subsequent instability highlights the challenges inherent in conflict mediation. The nomination underscores broader debates about how peace efforts are evaluated and rewarded, especially in regions with long-standing hostilities and deep geopolitical fault lines. As the Nobel Committee reviews this and other nominations, its decision will inevitably reflect broader questions about what constitutes genuine, lasting progress toward peace.
References
-
International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Safeguards Reports (2024): iaea.org
-
United Nations Security Council Resolutions on Iran: un.org/securitycouncil
-
Reuters, “Israel, Iran Exchange Fire Despite Ceasefire Announcement” (June 2025): reuters.com
-
Associated Press, “Iran Fires Missiles Despite Truce Effort” (June 2025): apnews.com
-
The Times of Israel, “US Mediates Ceasefire Amid Escalation” (June 2025): timesofisrael.com
